On the way back home to Tennessee from a weekend getaway in Georgia, I saw a billboard that said, “Every tongue shall confess that Jesus is Lord …. even the Democrats.”
I think it’s safe to say that the providers of that billboard think that Republicans have done a better job of confessing Jesus as Lord than the Democrats. As a man that is homegrown in Tennessee, I am used to this fallacy and idiocy. During my 10-plus-year stint in Christian ministry, I encountered this fallacy again and again.
For instance, I remember an elderly, white, sister in Christ disagreeing with the sticker on my truck, which proclaimed, “God is not a Republican … or a Democrat.” She thought otherwise. After all, she had chaired the county’s Republican party. She had studied the Bible and attended a Bible-studying church. Surely, God was a Republican! Surely, Republicans were the God-party, the Jesus-party!
As a committed Christian, and as a man of committed Christian faith, I find such thinking idiotic and repugnant. And for several reasons. For one, if one simply reads the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, one will see that Jesus cared about a lot more things than abortion and homosexuality, which are the favorite whipping-boys of Republican (pseudo)Christianity. For two, Jesus did not align with any existent political party of his own day; to think that he would align with a single American political party of our day is nothing more than self-justifying, special pleading. We want Jesus to endorse us.
Third, Jesus advocated a distinct politic: he advocated for a new way to be human, and for a new way to do human life together. He showed that the Jewish political factions did not have the answer to their problems. He showed that the Roman political management of their world did not provide the answer to their people, either. Pharisees? Nope. Sadducees? Nope, again. Zealots? Wrong. Caesar? Not the lord. Again and again, we see Jesus and his earliest followers recognizing the shortcomings–and blatant evils–of the rulers of their day. They did not look to secular political authorities to deliver them … or anyone else.
And neither should we. Are the Democrats flawed? Sure. Are the Republicans flawed? Certainly. Is one party more “Christian” than the other? Hardly. Have the Democrats confessed Jesus as Lord? As a political party, No, even if individual party members have made such verbal statements. Have the Republicans confessed Jesus as Lord? As a political party, Nope, even if individual party members have made such verbal statements. After all, if the Republican or Democrat parties were to confess Jesus as Lord fully, both of their agendas would wind up crucified, just like Jesus was. Right?